Skip to content
← AI articles

AI at work · Confidentiality

When company files pass through an employee’s personal AI account

7 min read

Reviewing a quote, translating a contract or summarising a financial spreadsheet can send confidential information to a provider the employer never approved when a personal AI account is used. To retain control over its data, management must define permitted uses and fund tools suited to the work.

The article in 30 seconds

  • Uploading a work document to a personal AI tool hands it to a provider the company may never have authorised.
  • A paid subscription is insufficient. The company must administer the accounts, fund the tools and specify which documents may be shared.
  • If a file is sent by mistake, reporting it quickly helps limit access, assess the consequences and take the necessary steps.
A hand holds an iPhone showing ChatGPT while blue and orange data flows into a blue cloud against a grainy red background.
AI-generated illustration.

In a tender, the customer and the sales representative work with different figures. The quote shows the price offered to the customer. The costing sheet sets out costs, margins and the discount the representative can still grant. Take a fictional example: a €180,000 offer, negotiable down to €165,000 if the contract is signed before the end of the quarter. When the representative asks a personal assistant to check the two files for consistency, they also reveal the minimum price and the negotiation deadline.

The information does not necessarily become visible to other users of the service. It has still been sent to an external provider. The representative was allowed to read the costing sheet. That permission did not extend to choosing a provider to receive a copy.

This has happened in practice. In March 2023, less than three weeks after allowing ChatGPT in its semiconductor division, Samsung identified three incidents, according to Economist Korea [1]. Two employees had pasted internal source code and a third had uploaded a meeting transcript. According to the newspaper, Samsung warned staff that it could not retrieve information sent to external servers. In May 2023, Samsung restricted generative AI use on its devices and internal networks [2]. These accounts establish that information was sent outside the company’s control. They do not establish that it was subsequently disclosed to other users.

Uploading a file creates a copy outside the company
The employee uploads an Excel fileFrom the company
The file travels over the internetNetwork operators
Encrypted transport
How long is the data retained? Where is it stored?
ChatGPT service servers

Simplified path. The tunnel represents encrypted transport. It does not represent a VPN. Check where the data is stored and how long it is kept for the plan and account settings in use.

What encryption protects

Encryption protects traffic in transit. The receiving service can still process the file. Encryption does not determine where it is stored or how long it is retained.

References: OpenAI’s commitments for business plans [3] and the privacy policy for individual users [4].

What the attachment reveals

The term shadow AI describes professional use of AI tools outside the company’s approved framework. A personal account is enough to create that parallel route. If a customer asks where their file was processed, IT may have to rely on the account holder to reconstruct what was sent and find any sharing links.

Sometimes one line makes a file sensitive. In a cash flow forecast, it shows the month when the company will need financing. In an IT architecture diagram, it identifies the legacy device still used for remote access. In a major customer’s specifications, a site address and delivery date can reveal a factory opening before it is announced. Removing the customer’s name leaves those clues in place.

The assistant’s answer deserves the same care. If a summary of the offer repeats the minimum price, a link to that conversation can expose the negotiating position as effectively as the spreadsheet.

A company account for approved documents

Management can set a common rule for everyone, including the executive team: all professional use of external AI must go through an individual account on a plan the company buys and administers. Personal accounts, including paid ones, fall outside that framework. The IT policy then specifies what each role can entrust to the selected service.

A common objection is that the employee pays for the account and has disabled the use of conversations for model training. That setting covers training. It does not on its own address retention, access or sharing, nor does it give the employer contractual protections and administrative controls. The company must check those safeguards separately.

A plan name such as “Business” or “Enterprise” is insufficient. Examine the plan, contract and features actually available. A work account does not authorise sending every company document.

For the tender, the policy might allow the quote to be reviewed while keeping the margin spreadsheet within the internal price approval process. Finance might restrict acquisition documents to a small group and prohibit sending them to any external AI. For an architecture diagram supplied by a customer, the signed confidentiality commitments also determine what processing is allowed.

There are legal implications too. Taking reasonable steps to protect confidentiality is one of three criteria for protection as a trade secret under Article L. 151-1 of the French Commercial Code [5]. Letting sensitive information circulate without rules can make those steps harder to demonstrate in a dispute.

The policy must also be enforceable. When it imposes general and permanent disciplinary obligations, French workplace rules apply. If internal regulations are already in place, the policy becomes an addition to them. The applicable formalities must be followed, including consulting the social and economic committee (CSE) where one exists, publishing the rules and submitting them to the labour inspectorate. A guide alone cannot replace that procedure. The absence of an enforceable policy does not mean no conduct can be sanctioned. The basis and circumstances of the breach still need to be examined. French Labour Code, Article L. 1321-5. [6]

Before signing, IT and, where needed, the legal and data protection teams check the terms for reusing files, how long files are kept and whether they can be deleted. The company also decides which connections to enable. Reviewing a quote requires access to that document. Giving the assistant access to the entire sales mailbox can expose negotiations with other customers. That decision warrants separate approval.

What an expense claim cannot solve

When an employee pays for an assistant, the cost stays outside the IT budget. The company still bears the risk of the files being processed. Reimbursing a personal subscription does not on its own transfer administration of the account, its history or its sharing settings to the employer. The difference becomes clear when the employee leaves.

Putting subscriptions in the budget lets the company assign licences according to business needs. Management can fund justified uses, reassign unused licences where the plan allows it and set up an access request for other staff. The rule on personal accounts must match the tools teams can actually use.

When the wrong file is sent

The quote offers a simple test. If the margin file is accidentally uploaded to a personal AI tool, the sales representative should know who to notify and be able to identify the documents, account and date involved.

Reporting takes a clear commitment from management. An employee who reports a mistake may also be admitting a policy breach. If they expect only punishment, they may keep quiet. The internal policy can encourage prompt, voluntary reporting without automatic penalties, while allowing a proportionate review of the circumstances, severity and any repetition.

With a personal account, the incident team often depends on the account holder’s cooperation. It asks them to revoke sharing links and start deleting the affected items while preserving the evidence needed for the investigation. The team may be unable to do this itself or verify deletion by the provider. It then assesses the consequences and any obligation to notify the customer.

Speed matters especially when the file contains personal data, such as someone’s contact details or a salary scale. An unauthorised upload can constitute a data breach. The controller must document it. If it is likely to pose a risk to people’s rights and freedoms, the controller must notify the competent authority, such as the CNIL in France where it has jurisdiction, without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours of becoming aware of it. Any delay must be justified. If the risk is high, affected people must generally be informed as well. The CNIL’s notification rules. [7]

Can the company establish which files were sent, to whom and on what terms? With a personal account, part of the answer can remain beyond its reach. Clear rules, managed tools and an incident reporting procedure help the company regain that control.

Sources and references

  1. according to Economist Korea ↩
  2. restricted generative AI use on its devices and internal networks ↩
  3. OpenAI’s commitments for business plans ↩
  4. the privacy policy for individual users ↩
  5. Article L. 151-1 of the French Commercial Code ↩
  6. French Labour Code, Article L. 1321-5. ↩
  7. The CNIL’s notification rules. ↩